Sign In
New User? Register
SherlockHolmesSocietyofIndia · Sherlockians- The Game is afoot
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can search the group for older messages.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
The bond of friendship   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #1667 of 2892 |
Dear Holmesians,
The enduring bond of friendship between Sherlock Holmes and Dr
Watson always intrigued me.

In celebrating Sherlock Holmes, we often forget the tolerance and
loyalty exhibited by Dr Watson in bearing with SH’s shortcomings. We
often find SH behaving in a callous manner towards the Good Doctor.
In“ The Adventure of the Dying Detective” , SH actually disparages
Dr
Watson’s medical knowledge though he subsequently explains that it
was done by him to convince Dr Watson to act as his messenger to get
Mr Culverton Smith to his lodgings.

SH is often abrupt with the Doctor though he later recovers his
good nature and tries to explain him the deduction involved. Despite
this, the Doctor’s loyalty is unflinching. Notice his conduct in the
Adventure of Charles Augustus Milverton when he insists accompanying
SH when he wants to burgle CAM’s house despite the danger of getting
caught. There are many more instances in the Canon, Devil’s Foot et
al.

Have we ever analyzed why Dr Watson was so loyal to Holmes in all
his adventures despite the dangers involved? It is also a pertinent
point that Dr Watson often neglected his own practice to accompany
SH. What was it that motivated Dr Watson to such heights of loyalty?
After all, the cases were that of Holmes.

I think this is a fit topic of discussion. Shall we?
Sumalsn











Fri Mar 10, 2006 3:35 pm

sumalsn
Offline Offline

Forward
Message #1667 of 2892 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Dear Holmesians, The enduring bond of friendship between Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson always intrigued me. In celebrating Sherlock Holmes, we often forget the...
sumalsn
Offline
Mar 10, 2006
3:35 pm

Sumal, For some reason, this posting of yours escaped my notice.Giver me a few days and I shall give my views on this bond of friendship between the two. ...
vijay singha
vp_singha
Online Send Email
Apr 19, 2006
2:40 pm

Dear all, sorry for not posting in anything for so long.I was on the family way and have recently been blessed with a baby boy. Logged in after a very long...
swati goswami
swatijaitly
Offline Send Email
Apr 22, 2006
9:16 am

Dear Holmesian, Congratulations and nice to have you back. I will try and post the programme schedule of the Adventures of Sherlock Holmes when I get it. Keep...
sumalsn
Offline
Apr 22, 2006
10:18 am

Dear Swati, It's nice to have you back. Heartiest congratulations( though a bit belated) on the new arrival in your family. May I, on behalf of all Holmesians...
vijay singha
vp_singha
Online Send Email
May 4, 2006
6:09 am

Dear VPS, Thanks for ur kind wishes. Hope u are doing well too.Its sweet that u treasure the 221B snap shots so much.I must confess it was one of the most...
swati goswami
swatijaitly
Offline Send Email
May 5, 2006
8:27 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help