Sign In
New User? Register
designindia
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can search the group for older messages.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Temple as a Public space   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #3289 of 13741 |
Re: [designindia] Temple as a Public space: reply to Korjans mail

Yes, Raja, it is nice to say sometimes that I exist.

I had been to this temple in Varanasi, and after
walking through a length of dirty wet corridor found
myself inside and there were these idols on the wall
worn by millions of people touching them. And as i put
my hand on one of them, i felt that connection - that
I too exist and am part of these millions of hands
before me. and the dirt and wet receded.

Maybe it is this sense of connection that is the crux
of design activity - this sense of having added a
word, a syllable, a moment of warmth to the language
of things.

regards
naga nandini
pd, 87, nid
bangalore

--- Raja Mohanty <rajam@...> wrote:

> Thankyou for the audience Vaibhav!
> To indulge for a brief while in mutual admiration- I
> was reading your
> father's book couple of days back- and sometimes
> while reading a book, I
> just like to feel the pages; since the book is
> produced nicely, I enjoy
> just looking at it- for there are energies that are
> radiated by paper-and
> one does not always have to read the words.
>
> The responses to Sudhir's post have been
> interesting- even those that I do
> not exactly align with, for they point to a
> different take on the matter-
> and everything- even the blasphemous can be sacred.
>
> To live with a sense of deep wonder and humility,
> accepting this,accepting
> that, absorbing, listening all the time- that is the
> nature of the spirit.
>
> and if instead of just listening - i utter, stutter
> and mutter, once in a
> while- it is perhaps because it is nice to say- i
> exist!
>
> a good year to you and all on this network.
>
> Raja
>
>
>
> > Dear Korjan
> > ram ram
> > its been a long time we have communicated, and i
> was
> > thinking of writing to you s i keep reading your
> > inputs on designIndia, but never manage to do it
> on
> > time.....
> > you know me very well!! but i am imroving
> nonetheless.
> >
> > I have been wondering to write something for the
> > recent 'hot discussion topic' initiated by sudhir.
> he
> > has done a brilliant job to bring this topic for
> > discussion.........and then in one of his emails
> > writing that 'it is good that design is looking at
> > industry, and now it is time design looks at
> > spirituality!'
> > then the whole discussion about institutionalising
> > religion...the good and the bad effects of the
> > process. in the changing 'socio-economic' paradigm
> > ruled by World-Bank notion of 'development' and
> > 'growth', i think this is going to happen and will
> > happen.
> > yesterday i was visiting Berlin wall 'Charlie
> > cheakpoint', and was amazed to see the marketing
> > brilliance of americo-european society, they have
> > managed to make a 'past' into marketable
> commodity,
> > and past which is not very distant either.
> > if you go around, see and experience..... it
> > exemplifies 'The Freedon is on sell, you can buy
> it if
> > you have enough money'!
> > In this light, like freedom, spirituality, as i
> > understnad, a basic human craving, will also
> follow
> > the trend. The Swaminarayan temples are leading
> the
> > path and temples in general will follow, with some
> > having more money doing it before than others.
> > but your input can be looked at with completely
> > different perspective.
> > A temple for design......i think its something to
> > reflect upon.
> > in this context, Raja mohanty's initial remark was
> > amusing, but did not find much audience.
> > so shall write about it if i find something to
> share
> > with you.
> >
> > regards, wishing you very besy new year
> >
> > vaibhav kaley
> > SID 94, CEPT
> > Bauhaus, Germany
> >
> > --- Dinesh Korjan <dinesh@...> wrote:
> >
> >> sometimes i wonder whether design is a good thing
> or
> >> a bad thing. maybe
> >> we need a temple for design where we can go to do
> >> some serious
> >> reflection on our actions?
> >>
> >> happy new year!
> >> dinesh korjan . studio korjan ahmedabad . nid pd
> >> 1976
> >>
> >> Sudhir Sharma wrote:
> >>
> >> > I am glad so many of us think similar on
> tempels
> >> in India.
> >> >
> >>
> >>
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > __________________________________
> > Yahoo! for Good - Make a difference this year.
> > http://brand.yahoo.com/cybergivingweek2005/
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > Yahoo! Groups Links
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
>
>





__________________________________
Yahoo! for Good - Make a difference this year.
http://brand.yahoo.com/cybergivingweek2005/



Tue Jan 3, 2006 4:36 am

naganandini
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #3289 of 13741 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

I am glad so many of us think similar on tempels in India. There is a basic difference between Indian culture and other cultures, we are really "social". I...
Sudhir Sharma
sudhirelephant
Offline Send Email
Dec 30, 2005
6:36 am

hi all i wish you all a very well designed and creative new year here i am sending some very intresting links, may be we can discuss them in coming year ...
ASH CHAU
ashgats
Offline Send Email
Dec 30, 2005
9:36 am

I find this stream of thought most interesting. What'll the promo ads say ? " We're the best designed temple complex .. with the most number of Gods you can...
Rajeev Manikoth
rmanikoth
Online Send Email
Dec 30, 2005
2:51 pm

sometimes i wonder whether design is a good thing or a bad thing. maybe we need a temple for design where we can go to do some serious reflection on our...
Dinesh Korjan
dkorjan
Offline Send Email
Dec 30, 2005
7:15 pm

Dear Dinesh, Rajeev and Sudhir Design, like science, mathematics, and philosophy is generally a good thing to have and put to use. It is how and where you use...
M P Ranjan
ranjanmp
Offline Send Email
Dec 31, 2005
5:45 am

Hi Ranjan Thought I'll stir up things a bit ! How're things with you? I heard that you were in Blr a couple of times. Drop in the next time you are here. ...
Rajeev Manikoth
rmanikoth
Online Send Email
Dec 31, 2005
6:08 am

Dear Korjan ram ram its been a long time we have communicated, and i was thinking of writing to you s i keep reading your inputs on designIndia, but never...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 2, 2006
2:26 pm

Thankyou for the audience Vaibhav! To indulge for a brief while in mutual admiration- I was reading your father's book couple of days back- and sometimes while...
Raja Mohanty
kingfish2050
Offline Send Email
Jan 2, 2006
4:18 pm

dear vaibhav, raja i don't seem to have received vaibhav's mail so thank you raja for quoting it in entirety in your reply. in recent times the same design...
Dinesh Korjan
dkorjan
Offline Send Email
Jan 2, 2006
7:57 pm

Dear Korjan ram ram i have been away traveling for a week now and could access my emails for brief time so the delay in reply. what you talk about 'problems...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 7, 2006
5:12 pm

... Vaibhav, I don't really agree with this view. In design, generally, in both education and practice it is centred around problems. Would you like to...
Dinesh Korjan
dkorjan
Offline Send Email
Jan 8, 2006
6:57 am

Vaibhav, I don't really agree with this view. In design, generally, in both education and practice it is centred around problems. Would you like to elaborate...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 10, 2006
11:41 am

Very interesting Vaibhav. I totally support your ideas of developing the capacity of asking questions rather than seeking solutions. This reminds me of my...
priya khatri
khatripa000
Offline Send Email
Jan 10, 2006
6:47 pm

we need to develop the processes and learn to articulate the questions...in order to provide answers. we shouldnt confuse tht the world needs answers from...
Sudhir Sharma
sudhirelephant
Offline Send Email
Jan 11, 2006
6:01 am

if u can spend endless time with your client questioning him about a job, you could aid him to design the entire thing, even if its a house or a car or a book....
deepak pathania
dpathania@...
Send Email
Jan 13, 2006
8:19 am

Dear Deepak Your description of the conversation between client and designer is very good indeed, It shows experience and clarity of the process for forming...
M P Ranjan
ranjanmp
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2006
2:48 pm

I think Vaibhav has taken this ahead nicely and articulated it well. Of course what me mean by questions DOES infact mean asking intelligent questions. ...
priya khatri
khatripa000
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2006
4:15 pm

dont write off the client too as yet, dont assume the the client is stupid either because he chooses to disregard your idea. fact is, if your doing design as a...
deepak pathania
dpathania@...
Send Email
Jan 14, 2006
7:38 am

Hi all, My 2 paise and small experience on Questions to ask a client: The attitude and approach of a designer is one of the most important intangible things...
Atul N Joshi
atulnjoshi
Offline Send Email
Jan 14, 2006
6:28 pm

I think the designer brings a qualitatively different viewpoint to the table and this is what creates 'design value'. It was Tom Peters, if I remember...
Deepankar Bhattacharyya
deepankar_bh...
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2006
10:13 am

Dear Priya, Deepak and Atul, ram ram it has been really interesting to read through and see the various approaches and perspectives about one issue, of 'asking...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 17, 2006
10:44 am

Dear Sudhir ram ram i appreciate your concern, but my argument is that if we are able to 'construct' questions, define problems much more accurately or...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2006
9:02 am

DSC-00465.jpg DSC-00466.jpg DSC-00467.jpg...
ranjanmp
Offline Send Email
Jan 21, 2006
7:08 am

Dear prof. Ranjan ram ram i could not open the attachment in your last emails. i would like to see the images, if it is convinient for you to send it again. ...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 24, 2006
12:09 am

Dear Priya ram ram actually i got interested in this whole idea of raising questions when i was reading a small but very interesting book called "Bharatiya...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 11, 2006
8:26 am

Yes, Raja, it is nice to say sometimes that I exist. I had been to this temple in Varanasi, and after walking through a length of dirty wet corridor found ...
Nandini
naganandini
Offline Send Email
Jan 3, 2006
4:38 am

Dear Raja ram ram thats such an incredible and beautiful comment i have heard for the book. the credit goes to the efforts and energy and love put in by...
Vaibhav Kaley
vaibhav94
Offline Send Email
Jan 4, 2006
9:47 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help