Re: [designindia] Re: regarding mail ending protocols
Mail end protocol helps everyone. It tells you about who you are and
what you do in the shortest possible way.
There are no Big Bs or SRKs in this forum (for example) – who didn't
need the mail end protocol. For ordinary mortals like us, little self
introduction doesn't harm anyone. Only reason I can think of not
writing it is when I have posted three mails in a day or when I have
simply forgotten.
This forum connects three generation of designers in India and many in
the world. The pioneers of sixties, the freshers of today and everyone
else in between. If that is not 'inclusive' then I don't know what
this oft-quoted term means. Far from being embarrassed at being asked
my age, I would be happy to be considered a senior child of design!
It is not meant to be judgemental about how old the writers are, their
current position or where they have been privileged enough to have
studied. The information merely help connects people in a virtual
medium. It removes the impersonality of communication to show that
behind every letter there is no ghost writer, but a real person who
affirms responsibility for what s/he is writing.
It also helps 'place' the person into context and enables people to
connect with long lost buddies. Writing only name isn't enough. With
the same name there may exist completely different personalities –
each one of them being unique. It helps to know which of the Ms/Mr X
we are interacting with.
It doesn't matter whether the subject studied by the writer in college
have become extinct or obsolete. Knowing that information alone may
benefit someone in future to contact him/her as a resource person –
should there be any need.
It is not a practical idea to go search for profile of writers every
time one receives a mail. Many of us read the mail in email programmes
and not in web browsers.
Finally, what the other forums are doing or not doing shouldn't be
any reason for us not trying it. This is my personal opinion and not
as one of the moderators'. I read this quote only today and here's my
chance for sharing it:
"I passionately hate the idea of being with it; I think an artist has
always to be out of step with his time".
(Orson Welles, – American writer, actor, director of "Citizen Kane"
and other famous movies)
Cheers
Sagarmoy Paul (alias Sagar)
Communication Designer
VC-NID-1981-87
THOUGHTSCAPE
New Delhi
I think it is important to have the mailend protocol for a meaningful discussion. I wish this group software was something like facebook..where your profiles...
Mail end protocol helps everyone. It tells you about who you are and what you do in the shortest possible way. There are no Big Bs or SRKs in this forum (for...
Sagarmoy Paul
sagarmoypaul@...
Dec 2, 2007 6:04 pm
Hi Sagarmoy, Siddharth and Sudhir, Thankyou. Three powerful responses in favor of the current mail end protocol and all others either concur or are duly...
... Here is something that I found amusing on this issue of : Identifying yourself" along with your post! and taht being Mandatory! A friend of mine , a very...
"Mandatory" would indicate that a lapse will directly create punitive action by the list-owner. And so far as I know, there has been no mention of punitive...
Dear Pankaj, So do you suggest that after going through a long mail like you have written, I should be looking up again somewhere else to find out who 'Mr...
Dear Siddarth, Firstly - is it not a fact that some people are resisting putting the information? If things are that simple to put in an automated signature...
This is such a superfluous discussion. When it comes to emails on this forum, most of us have an idea of who is saying what - and newcomers are introduced...
Dear Avy, I can speak for myself at least! Having been a member since last three years, i really fail to recognise people from their short names like 'Avy' or...
At the end of the day, its about my willingness to express my identity the way I wish - I may or may not want to be placed exactly the way someone else wishes...
Dear Saumitri, I expressed my difficulty and expectation from this forum regarding communication. It was my humble submission of my 'inabilities' to cope with ...
Hi! Much has been said about the mail ending protocols. None of the side is in a mood to concede to other. A lot of creative energy has gone into the...
Sure, Hrridayesh - if its a rule, then it should be followed. I was trying to point out that its not a rule, but a recommendation. Sudhir has never said that...
Dear Pankaj: Mention of the word Rule is an expression. In many of the meanings of word Rule the most appropriate meaning of it in this context is given by...
(-: This protocol is for ending the discussion on mail ending protocal :-) Dinesh ... Dinesh Katre, Ph.D.(HCI) Group Coordinator National Multimedia Resource...
Dear friends This whole discussion is quite distressing. While it is important to know who is speaking, so full names rather than initials only and current...
I agree with Ranjan on this. I think which institute and which year does lead to a bais in terms of age and qualification and therefore assumed expertness and...
Think Design Collaborative is looking for a Full time Graphic Designer for their office in New Delhi. Company Profile: Think Design was founded in 2004 by...
check this requirement you see what everybody looks for. Look at the points that I have have hilighted amit ... [Non-text portions of this message have been...
I think we are blowing it out of proportion. In the beginning the forum was small, the members knew each other personally. As it grew it became imperative to...
Sagarmoy Paul
sagarmoypaul@...
Dec 4, 2007 6:29 am
We do put our name in the end of our writing, dont we?..why do we do that, mailend protocol is just another convinience for everyone to know who are you, and...
Sagarmoy,
There isn't much we have agreed upon in the past or now but I don't think expressing a need for "flexibility" (as opposed to "mandatory"-by...
Uma My assumption is, by now most people have had enough of this nagging discussion. And at least I have got better things to do than responding to your...
Sagarmoy Paul
sagarmoypaul@...
Dec 4, 2007 3:58 pm
Sagarmoy Your assumption is probaly rights and I am glad to hear you have better things to do as I do too. I have made my points and you have made yours. ...
if i didnt know anything about sudhir, i would come to a conclusion that sudhir is an elephant from london ... maybe then some more info is required regards ...
deepak pathania
designtalk@...
Dec 7, 2007 9:26 am
Good one Deepak :-) ha ha. ... that sudhir is an elephant from london ... (2006-2008) ... <http://www.design-concepts-and-concerns.blogspot.com> ... ...
ofcourse !-) i agree the levels are different- there may be differing consequences to non conformation... i raised the issue just to co-relate our disparate...