Sign In
New User? Register
indiansciencefiction · The indiansciencefiction group
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can set the sort order of messages? Just click on the link in the date column. Your preferences will be remembered, so you don't have to do it again when you return.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Messages 1746 - 1775 of 3488   Newest  |  < Newer  |  Older >  |  Oldest
Messages: Show Message Summaries   (Group by Topic) Sort by Date v  
#1775 From: "swapnil.bhartiya" <arnieswap@...>
Date:: Sun Jun 1, 2008 11:38 am
Subject:: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
swapnil.bhar...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Dear Gene,

I trust  you read this article of mine. If you haven't I request you
do. I talked to people at ISO, OpenOffice.org, Sun, IBM and Red Hat. I
also talked to Microsoft. So, I expect you to read it and then
comment, this is an important issue of our times.

Swapnil


--- In indiansciencefiction@..., Gene van Troyer
<gevantry@...> wrote:
>
> On 6/1/08 1:44 AM, "swapnil BHARTIYA" <arnieswap@...> wrote:
>
> >> I trust you, like me and others, must be using computers to create
> >> documents -- letters, stories, articles, etc. If you are using
Windows
> >> (which I don't use), you must be saving it in .doc format. Now, that
> >> format is being created using a proprietary technology of Microsoft.
> >> In future if Microsoft shuts down, you will not be able to access
that
> >> data. Someone will have to reverse engineer the fomat and see the
> >> data, and there can never be 100 % fidility in that. Now, look at
> >> governments which handle data in larger size....election commission
> >> has millions of active voters database. If that database is also in
> >> proprietary format, its a critical situation where the entire
database
> >> of a nation depends on the survival of a company. Which could not be
> >> accepted. However, this will give you clearer picture...
> >>
> In truth, there are many problems in recognizing any proprietary
software
> formats as acceptable international format standards. That is why
> governments and other public institutions should forego deploying any
> company¹s software for any public purpose unless that company guarantees
> that the formatting will be accessible by any OS platform. This
problem has
> been scandalous over the last few years, in as much as many
governments have
> signed agreements with Microsoft to install information sharing
systems on
> line that require the citizenry to use Microsoft products if they
wish to
> use government services on line. In the USA, Canada, and EU this has
sparked
> massive citizen protests and lawsuits, since governments that do
this are in
> effect telling citizens and other public institutions that they bust buy
> Microsoft products. This is nothing less than using taxpayer money to
> support a business monopoly.
>
> This is why the above named governments are being forced by its
citizens to
> to use Open Source information sharing systems which have formats
that work
> on any operating system such as Mac OSX, Linux, Windows, Solaris, OS/2,
> UNIX, and so on. While the operating systems themselves (except
Linux) are
> proprietary, Open Source formats are designed to work with all, of
them. In
> many countries, it has become illegal for taxpayer supported
institutions to
> continue using data sharing software that requires proprietary formats.
>
> Here in Japan, I am furious with the Japanese government around tax
time,
> because I cannot use online government services to handle tax
matters. The
> online systems are Windows-based and require citizens to use Windows
> software and Internet Explorer. This significantly complicates
procedures
> for me and tens of thousands of other citizens and residents of
Japan who
> feel that the government has no business telling us that we have
have to go
> out and buy Microsoft products. We quite rightly raise serious questions
> pertaining to collusion, graft, corruption, bribery, kickbacks, and
other
> actions on the part of public officials when it comes to Microsoft
and the
> proper use of taxpayer money.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Gene van Troyer
>

#1774 From: "swapnil.bhartiya" <arnieswap@...>
Date:: Sun Jun 1, 2008 2:17 am
Subject:: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
swapnil.bhar...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Here in India while central government is not clear about which format
to go for (due to Microsoft pressure), many state governments have gone
to FOSS and GNU/Linux exclusively -- Kerala, Tamil Nadu and even Delhi
Government. But the employees or officers are still using Windows
because they don't want to spend few minutes in understanding the use of
Linux which is much more simpler and continue using Windows which
eventually gets paid by taxpayer's money.

However FOSS people are active in India and they will ensure that no
public data should be craeted using proprietary technologies. Let's hope
it happens.

Swapnil


--- In indiansciencefiction@..., Gene van Troyer
<gevantry@...> wrote:
>
> On 6/1/08 1:44 AM, "swapnil BHARTIYA" arnieswap@... wrote:
>
> >> I trust you, like me and others, must be using computers to create
> >> documents -- letters, stories, articles, etc. If you are using
Windows
> >> (which I don't use), you must be saving it in .doc format. Now,
that
> >> format is being created using a proprietary technology of
Microsoft.
> >> In future if Microsoft shuts down, you will not be able to access
that
> >> data. Someone will have to reverse engineer the fomat and see the
> >> data, and there can never be 100 % fidility in that. Now, look at
> >> governments which handle data in larger size....election commission
> >> has millions of active voters database. If that database is also in
> >> proprietary format, its a critical situation where the entire
database
> >> of a nation depends on the survival of a company. Which could not
be
> >> accepted. However, this will give you clearer picture...
> >>
> In truth, there are many problems in recognizing any proprietary
software
> formats as acceptable international format standards. That is why
> governments and other public institutions should forego deploying any
> company¹s software for any public purpose unless that company
guarantees
> that the formatting will be accessible by any OS platform. This
problem has
> been scandalous over the last few years, in as much as many
governments have
> signed agreements with Microsoft to install information sharing
systems on
> line that require the citizenry to use Microsoft products if they wish
to
> use government services on line. In the USA, Canada, and EU this has
sparked
> massive citizen protests and lawsuits, since governments that do this
are in
> effect telling citizens and other public institutions that they bust
buy
> Microsoft products. This is nothing less than using taxpayer money to
> support a business monopoly.
>
> This is why the above named governments are being forced by its
citizens to
> to use Open Source information sharing systems which have formats that
work
> on any operating system such as Mac OSX, Linux, Windows, Solaris,
OS/2,
> UNIX, and so on. While the operating systems themselves (except Linux)
are
> proprietary, Open Source formats are designed to work with all, of
them. In
> many countries, it has become illegal for taxpayer supported
institutions to
> continue using data sharing software that requires proprietary
formats.
>
> Here in Japan, I am furious with the Japanese government around tax
time,
> because I cannot use online government services to handle tax matters.
The
> online systems are Windows-based and require citizens to use Windows
> software and Internet Explorer. This significantly complicates
procedures
> for me and tens of thousands of other citizens and residents of Japan
who
> feel that the government has no business telling us that we have have
to go
> out and buy Microsoft products. We quite rightly raise serious
questions
> pertaining to collusion, graft, corruption, bribery, kickbacks, and
other
> actions on the part of public officials when it comes to Microsoft and
the
> proper use of taxpayer money.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Gene van Troyer
>

#1773 From: "arvind mishra" <drarvind3@...>
Date:: Sun Jun 1, 2008 12:57 am
Subject:: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
drarvind3@...
Send Email Send Email
 
Thanks Gene for putting the topic in perspective.
arvind
2008/6/1 Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>:

On 6/1/08 1:44 AM, "swapnil BHARTIYA" <arnieswap@...> wrote:

I trust you, like me and others, must be using computers to create
documents -- letters, stories, articles, etc. If you are using Windows
(which I don't use), you must be saving it in .doc format. Now, that
format is being created using a proprietary technology of Microsoft.
In future if Microsoft shuts down, you will not be able to access that
data. Someone will have to reverse engineer the fomat and see the
data, and there can never be 100 % fidility in that. Now, look at
governments which handle data in larger size....election commission
has millions of active voters database. If that database is also in
proprietary format, its a critical situation where the entire database
of a nation depends on the survival of a company. Which could not be
accepted. However, this will give you clearer picture...

In truth, there are many problems in recognizing any proprietary software formats as acceptable international format standards. That is why governments and other public institutions should forego deploying any company's software for any public purpose unless that company guarantees that the formatting will be accessible by any OS platform. This problem has been scandalous over the last few years, in as much as many governments have signed agreements with Microsoft to install information sharing systems on line that require the citizenry to use Microsoft products if they wish to use government services on line. In the USA, Canada, and EU this has sparked massive citizen protests and lawsuits, since governments that do this are in effect telling citizens and other public institutions that they bust buy Microsoft products. This is nothing less than using taxpayer money to support a business monopoly.

This is why the above named governments are being forced by its citizens to to use Open Source information sharing systems which have formats that work on any operating system such as Mac OSX, Linux, Windows, Solaris, OS/2, UNIX, and so on. While the operating systems themselves (except Linux) are proprietary, Open Source formats are designed to work with all, of them. In many countries, it has become illegal for taxpayer supported institutions to continue using data sharing software that requires proprietary formats.

Here in Japan, I am furious with the Japanese government around tax time, because I cannot use online government services to handle tax matters. The online systems are Windows-based and require citizens to use Windows software and Internet Explorer. This significantly complicates procedures for me and tens of thousands of other citizens and residents of Japan who feel that the government has no business telling us that we have have to go out and buy Microsoft products. We quite rightly raise serious questions pertaining to collusion, graft, corruption, bribery, kickbacks, and other actions on the part of public officials when it comes to Microsoft and the proper use of taxpayer money.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer



--
arvind mishra

#1772 From: "ML Gupta" <mlguptavns@...>
Date:: Sun Jun 1, 2008 12:54 am
Subject:: Re: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Swapnil
Thanks a lot ,as you have elaborated the subject in a lucid way its now quite understandable.
It has ignited my interest in the subject.
Thanks again.
ml

On Sat, 31 May 2008 swapnil BHARTIYA wrote :
>Dear Mr Gupta.
>
>I trust you, like me and others, must be using computers to create
>documents -- letters, stories, articles, etc. If you are using Windows
>(which I don't use), you must be saving it in .doc format. Now, that
>format is being created using a proprietary technology of Microsoft.
>In future if Microsoft shuts down, you will not be able to access that
>data. Someone will have to reverse engineer the fomat and see the
>data, and there can never be 100 % fidility in that. Now, look at
>governments which handle data in larger size....election commission
>has millions of active voters database. If that database is also in
>proprietary format, its a critical situation where the entire database
>of a nation depends on the survival of a company. Which could not be
>accepted. However, this will give you clearer picture:
>
>Hypothesis 1: Year 2090
>The small pox epidemic breaks out in 2090 and people are dying. The
>disease was believed to have been eradicated in the 1980s. The
>government can control the situation but needs to look back at the
>data of 1984, the year the disease was overcome. But when health
>officials examine the pool of data, they find that it is encoded in a
>proprietary format that they cannot decode. By this time, the company
>that controlled the format has shut its business and ventured into
>other profitable
>domains. The company says that support for that format ended 60 years
>ago, and now they have no means to help. The government has the
>solution in its hands, but is unable to get to it to help the people.
>It watches helplessly as the epidemic spreads and peopledie. A nation
>that depended on proprietary technology becomes helpless.
>
>Fact 1: Year 1995
>Iran was pounded with US sanctions and all US-based companies were
>barred from operating in the country. The entire IT infrastructure
>that was dependent on US-based companies came to a halt. Basic
>facilities like railway ticket reservations, issuing and paying
>electric bills, as well as
>advanced services—everything came under siege. Since the companies
>could not offer any support or services, the country was left high and
>dry, as the technologies were proprietary and the most brilliant
>engineers could not do a thing. Then free software came to the rescue
>and a nation that had been brought to its knees, stood tall again.
>
>These two cases show how fatal it could be to depend on closed or
>proprietary technologies.
>
>The story deals with the issue of Microsoft coming out with a
>technology and misguiding everyone that it is open, thus its very
>important for governments to realise which technology to go for.
>
>The story deals with the same issue...
>
>hope it helps....
>
>Swapnil
>
>
>
>
>On Sat, May 31, 2008 at 9:48 PM, ML Gupta <mlguptavns@...> wrote:
> >  Swapnil
> > For a lay person in the field like me please introduce the subject first
> > with of course a brief commentary on  your stand on it and then may be an
> > interested guy  is lured to read  a pdf on it.
> > Would you deliver please ?
> > ml
> >
> >
> > On Sat, 31 May 2008 swapnil.bhartiya wrote :
> >
> >>Dear All
> >>
> >>This is a serious issue. This month I did a major story on Microsoft's
> >>OOXML format and the manner it got approved at ISO, which raises a lot
> >>of questions on ISO as a body itself. Also this story calls for
> >>government bodies to be more careful while picking up proprietary
> >>technologies.
> >>
> >>The story is attached at PDF. You can access this file at the URL:
> >>http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/files/OOXML.pdf
> >>
> >>Swapnil Bhartiya
> >>Assistant Editor
> >>EFYTimes.com
> >>
> >>
> >
> >
> >
>
>
>
>--
>Swapnil Bhartiya
>Assistant Editor
>EFYTimes.com
>
>*I use LINUX, what do you use? *
>
>------------------------------------
>
>Yahoo! Groups Links
>
><*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
>    http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/
>
><*> Your email settings:
>    Individual Email | Traditional
>
><*> To change settings online go to:
>    http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/join
>    (Yahoo! ID required)
>
><*> To change settings via email:
>    mailto:indiansciencefiction-digest@...
>    mailto:indiansciencefiction-fullfeatured@...
>
><*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
>    indiansciencefiction-unsubscribe@...
>
><*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
>    http://in.docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
>



Paddle Pop

#1771 From: Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 10:42 pm
Subject:: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
gevantry
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
On 6/1/08 1:44 AM, "swapnil BHARTIYA" <arnieswap@...> wrote:

I trust you, like me and others, must be using computers to create
documents -- letters, stories, articles, etc. If you are using Windows
(which I don't use), you must be saving it in .doc format. Now, that
format is being created using a proprietary technology of Microsoft.
In future if Microsoft shuts down, you will not be able to access that
data. Someone will have to reverse engineer the fomat and see the
data, and there can never be 100 % fidility in that. Now, look at
governments which handle data in larger size....election commission
has millions of active voters database. If that database is also in
proprietary format, its a critical situation where the entire database
of a nation depends on the survival of a company. Which could not be
accepted. However, this will give you clearer picture...

In truth, there are many problems in recognizing any proprietary software formats as acceptable international format standards. That is why governments and other public institutions should forego deploying any company’s software for any public purpose unless that company guarantees that the formatting will be accessible by any OS platform. This problem has been scandalous over the last few years, in as much as many governments have signed agreements with Microsoft to install information sharing systems on line that require the citizenry to use Microsoft products if they wish to use government services on line. In the USA, Canada, and EU this has sparked massive citizen protests and lawsuits, since governments that do this are in effect telling citizens and other public institutions that they bust buy Microsoft products. This is nothing less than using taxpayer money to support a business monopoly.

This is why the above named governments are being forced by its citizens to to use Open Source information sharing systems which have formats that work on any operating system such as Mac OSX, Linux, Windows, Solaris, OS/2, UNIX, and so on. While the operating systems themselves (except Linux) are proprietary, Open Source formats are designed to work with all, of them. In many countries, it has become illegal for taxpayer supported institutions to continue using data sharing software that requires proprietary formats.

Here in Japan, I am furious with the Japanese government around tax time, because I cannot use online government services to handle tax matters. The online systems are Windows-based and require citizens to use Windows software and Internet Explorer. This significantly complicates procedures for me and tens of thousands of other citizens and residents of Japan who feel that the government has no business telling us that we have have to go out and buy Microsoft products. We quite rightly raise serious questions pertaining to collusion, graft, corruption, bribery, kickbacks, and other actions on the part of public officials when it comes to Microsoft and the proper use of taxpayer money.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer

#1770 From: "swapnil BHARTIYA" <arnieswap@...>
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 4:44 pm
Subject:: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
swapnil.bhar...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Dear Mr Gupta.

I trust you, like me and others, must be using computers to create
documents -- letters, stories, articles, etc. If you are using Windows
(which I don't use), you must be saving it in .doc format. Now, that
format is being created using a proprietary technology of Microsoft.
In future if Microsoft shuts down, you will not be able to access that
data. Someone will have to reverse engineer the fomat and see the
data, and there can never be 100 % fidility in that. Now, look at
governments which handle data in larger size....election commission
has millions of active voters database. If that database is also in
proprietary format, its a critical situation where the entire database
of a nation depends on the survival of a company. Which could not be
accepted. However, this will give you clearer picture:

Hypothesis 1: Year 2090
The small pox epidemic breaks out in 2090 and people are dying. The
disease was believed to have been eradicated in the 1980s. The
government can control the situation but needs to look back at the
data of 1984, the year the disease was overcome. But when health
officials examine the pool of data, they find that it is encoded in a
proprietary format that they cannot decode. By this time, the company
that controlled the format has shut its business and ventured into
other profitable
domains. The company says that support for that format ended 60 years
ago, and now they have no means to help. The government has the
solution in its hands, but is unable to get to it to help the people.
It watches helplessly as the epidemic spreads and peopledie. A nation
that depended on proprietary technology becomes helpless.

Fact 1: Year 1995
Iran was pounded with US sanctions and all US-based companies were
barred from operating in the country. The entire IT infrastructure
that was dependent on US-based companies came to a halt. Basic
facilities like railway ticket reservations, issuing and paying
electric bills, as well as
advanced services—everything came under siege. Since the companies
could not offer any support or services, the country was left high and
dry, as the technologies were proprietary and the most brilliant
engineers could not do a thing. Then free software came to the rescue
and a nation that had been brought to its knees, stood tall again.

These two cases show how fatal it could be to depend on closed or
proprietary technologies.

The story deals with the issue of Microsoft coming out with a
technology and misguiding everyone that it is open, thus its very
important for governments to realise which technology to go for.

The story deals with the same issue...

hope it helps....

Swapnil




On Sat, May 31, 2008 at 9:48 PM, ML Gupta <mlguptavns@...> wrote:
>   Swapnil
> For a lay person in the field like me please introduce the subject first
> with of course a brief commentary on  your stand on it and then may be an
> interested guy  is lured to read  a pdf on it.
> Would you deliver please ?
> ml
>
>
> On Sat, 31 May 2008 swapnil.bhartiya wrote :
>
>>Dear All
>>
>>This is a serious issue. This month I did a major story on Microsoft's
>>OOXML format and the manner it got approved at ISO, which raises a lot
>>of questions on ISO as a body itself. Also this story calls for
>>government bodies to be more careful while picking up proprietary
>>technologies.
>>
>>The story is attached at PDF. You can access this file at the URL:
>>http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/files/OOXML.pdf
>>
>>Swapnil Bhartiya
>>Assistant Editor
>>EFYTimes.com
>>
>>
>
>
>



--
Swapnil Bhartiya
Assistant Editor
EFYTimes.com

*I use LINUX, what do you use? *

#1769 From: "ML Gupta" <mlguptavns@...>
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 4:18 pm
Subject:: Re: What Format Should Governments Choose!
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

  Swapnil
For a lay person in the field like me please introduce the subject first with of course a brief commentary on  your stand on it and then may be an interested guy  is lured to read  a pdf on it.
Would you deliver please ?
ml


On Sat, 31 May 2008 swapnil.bhartiya wrote :
>Dear All
>
>This is a serious issue. This month I did a major story on Microsoft's
>OOXML format and the manner it got approved at ISO, which raises a lot
>of questions on ISO as a body itself. Also this story calls for
>government bodies to be more careful while picking up proprietary
>technologies.
>
>The story is attached at PDF. You can access this file at the URL:
>http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/files/OOXML.pdf
>
>Swapnil Bhartiya
>Assistant Editor
>EFYTimes.com
>
>



Amity

#1768 From: "arvind mishra" <drarvind3@...>
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 2:47 pm
Subject:: Re: New file uploaded to indiansciencefiction
drarvind3@...
Send Email Send Email
 
Thanks Swapnil for sharing this very informative file-shall read leisurely .
2008/5/31 <indiansciencefiction@...>:


Hello,

This email message is a notification to let you know that
a file has been uploaded to the Files area of the indiansciencefiction
group.

File : /OOXML.pdf
Uploaded by : swapnil.bhartiya <arnieswap@...>
Description : Choice For Govt

You can access this file at the URL:
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/files/OOXML.pdf

To learn more about file sharing for your group, please visit:
http://help.yahoo.com/help/in/groups/files

Regards,

swapnil.bhartiya <arnieswap@...>





--
arvind mishra

#1767 From: "swapnil.bhartiya" <arnieswap@...>
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 2:33 pm
Subject:: What Format Should Governments Choose!
swapnil.bhar...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Dear All

This is a serious issue. This month I did a major story on Microsoft's
OOXML format and the manner it got approved at ISO, which raises a lot
of questions on ISO as a body itself. Also this story calls for
government bodies to be more careful while picking up proprietary
technologies.

The story is attached at PDF. You can access this file at the URL:
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/files/OOXML.pdf

Swapnil Bhartiya
Assistant Editor
EFYTimes.com

#1766 From: indiansciencefiction@...
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 2:29 pm
Subject:: New file uploaded to indiansciencefiction
indiansciencefiction@...
Send Email Send Email
 
Hello,

This email message is a notification to let you know that
a file has been uploaded to the Files area of the indiansciencefiction
group.

   File        : /OOXML.pdf
   Uploaded by : swapnil.bhartiya <arnieswap@...>
   Description : Choice For Govt

You can access this file at the URL:
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/indiansciencefiction/files/OOXML.pdf

To learn more about file sharing for your group, please visit:
http://help.yahoo.com/help/in/groups/files

Regards,

swapnil.bhartiya <arnieswap@...>

#1765 From: "arvind mishra" <arvind_drmishra@...>
Date:: Sat May 31, 2008 2:17 pm
Subject:: Re: Those 'first'sf stories !
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Friends,

There appears to be no dissent till now on the issue of the 'first Indian  sf story ' as specified by me in the previous post.

It appears then that  Hindi serial  sf ,'The Aaschrya Vrittant -'A Strange Tale '[1884-1888] by Ambika Datt Vyas definitely enjoys the status of being the first Indian sf story.

SF writing in many other Indian languages seems to have been initiated much later.In Malayalam for instance sf writing appears to have  been initiated since 1950,with the initiative taken by Keral Sastra Sahity Parishad-a most   respected autonomous body of science popularization in India.

Similarly,Assamese language with its very laudable role and history in science writings stepped into the arena of sf writing in the late 1930's.

Kannada follows almost similar suite which is stated to be in sf writing since 1940's with the advent of Dr.Sadanand Nayak with his famous sf love story employing a plot on heart transplant.

In Marathi too though SF writing started late around 1910 with the publication of a translation of Verne's  'Men in the Moon' serialized in a magazine named 'Kerala Kokil' printed and published in Cochin,it enjoys a coveted -very rich contemporary status in sf writings in  India.

In yet another prominent Indian Language ,Tamil the history of sf writing could be traced  back to 1959,of course a very late beginning, in writings of a great poet[Mhakavi],C.Subramania Bhartiya whose story entitled ,'Kakkai Parliament[Parliament of the crows] has some sf elements.

Having presented this account I am tempted to conclude that Hindi ,the lingua franca of India evidently took a leading role in sf writing but what is it's  present scenario is altogether a different story -to be narrated at some other time and space.

arvind





--- In indiansciencefiction@..., "arvind mishra" <arvind_drmishra@...> wrote:
>
> Friends,
> Do you know for certain which is the first Indian sf story ?
> Confused ? Quite genuinely so !Because the question is not correctly put
> here ,it would have been more precise to add 'in which language' too to
> help out retrieving some immediate answers.
> This may be controversial though but taking this risk I put forward some
> of my observations here.
> The first Indian sf -'the westerns style-modern' one was written in
> Hindi as a serial during 1884-88 by Ambika Dutt Vyas entitled 'the
> starnge tale-[aaschary vrittant] ,published in a magazine -Peeyush
> Pravah from Madhy Pradesh.Influenced perhaps by the Jules Verne's story
> ,'Journey to the center of the earth' it presents a very
> interesting,captivating saga of Gopinath,the main protagonist who takes
> a breathtaking adventurous journey underneath the earth.
> Though influenced seemingly by a western stuff the story was an original
> effort in style and presentation vis a vis to contemporary short story
> writings in Hindi .
> Another story which caught attention of the genre connoisseur's was
> written by an icon in Indian scientific world -J.C Bose -a Bengali
> jentleman and scientist of repute and was entitled 'Absconded
> Tempest'[Palatak toofan'-1896]which narrates a captivating story how a
> turbulent sea was calmed with even a minuscule thing- as ordinary as a
> drop of oil.The story bears a strange semblance with the 'chaos theory'
> propounded much later.A discussion on this strange semblance appears on
> 'Science Fiction in India' <http://indiascifiarvind.blogspot.com/> .
> Let me hear your voice up to this part of the post before taking up
> some other First Sf stories in Indian languages.
> best,
> arvind
>

#1764 From: "arvind mishra" <arvind_drmishra@...>
Date:: Wed May 28, 2008 3:23 am
Subject:: Those 'first'sf stories !
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Friends,
Do you know for certain which is the first Indian sf story ?
Confused ? Quite genuinely so !Because the question is not correctly put here ,it would have been more precise to add 'in which language' too to help out retrieving some immediate answers.
This may be controversial though but taking this risk I put forward some of my observations here.
The first Indian sf -'the westerns style-modern' one  was written in Hindi as a serial during 1884-88 by Ambika Dutt Vyas entitled 'the starnge tale-[aaschary vrittant] ,published in a magazine -Peeyush Pravah from Madhy Pradesh.Influenced perhaps by the Jules Verne's story ,'Journey to the center of the earth' it presents a very interesting,captivating saga of Gopinath,the main protagonist who takes a breathtaking adventurous journey underneath the earth.
Though influenced seemingly by a western stuff the story was an original effort in style and presentation vis a vis to contemporary short story writings in Hindi .
Another story which caught attention of the  genre connoisseur's  was written by  an  icon in Indian scientific world -J.C Bose -a Bengali jentleman and scientist of repute and was entitled 'Absconded Tempest'[Palatak toofan'-1896]which narrates a captivating story  how a turbulent sea was calmed with even a minuscule thing- as ordinary as a drop of oil.The story bears a strange semblance with the 'chaos theory' propounded much later.A discussion on this strange semblance appears on 'Science Fiction in India' .
Let me hear your voice up to this  part of the post before taking up some other First Sf stories in Indian languages.
best,
arvind

#1763 From: Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>
Date:: Tue May 27, 2008 11:02 pm
Subject:: Re: It seems to be a golden opportunity.......
gevantry
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
On 5/26/08 3:19 PM, "CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL" <cmnautiyal@...> wrote:

Thanks Gene for cautioning.  There are several like this running (one is on poetry where almost every poem makes to the final round and the prospective poet is tempeted to buy the book.  And you never know, the pound 100 may not go to anyone at all.  Sincerely  CM Nautiyal  CMN

You’re welcome. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of poetry and other writing contests out there. Some are reputable and have meaning in the writing world, but too many are just scams that take advantage of the hopes of inexperienced writers to get published and become recognized. You need to be careful.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer

#1762 From: CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...>
Date:: Mon May 26, 2008 6:19 am
Subject:: Re: It seems to be a golden opportunity.......
cmnautiyal
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Thanks genes for cautioning.  There are several like this running (one is on poetry where almost every poem makes to the final round and the prospective poet is tempeted to buy the book.  And you never know, the pound 100 may not go to anyone at all.

 

Sincerely

 

CM Nautiyal

 

CMN

Dr. Chandra Mohan Nautiyal
MSc (UOR/IIT-R); PhD (PRL/ GU); FGS (I); F-NCSTC-NW; Member Executive, Vigyan Parishad
 
Scientist-in-Charge, Radiocarbon Lab.
Geophysical and Geochemical Investigations in Relation to Quaternary Palaeoclimate Reconstruction
BSIP, 53, University Road, Lucknow- 226007.  INDIA
Phone : 0522-2712218 (Res), 2740008, 2740011 (Off),      Mob : 091-09415107078
 

 


--- On Fri, 23/5/08, Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...> wrote:
From: Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>
Subject: Re: [indiansciencefiction] It seems to be a golden opportunity.......
To: "indiansciencefiction" <indiansciencefiction@...>
Date: Friday, 23 May, 2008, 9:35 PM

My take on this is: enter at your own risk. It’s obviously a business. The people running the contest charge you £5 per entry. If they get a few hundred people at a time to enter and pay out only about  Â£200 per contest, they’re pulling in a few hundred (maybe a few thousand) pounds a month.

If you’re not familiar with entering contests, I suggest you do a bit of research on the practice to make sure you’re entering competitions that actually matter. This one doesn’t. It’s a business venture run by some outfit called Certys Limited. You, the contest entrant, appear to be the company’s prospective cash cow.

Just thought I’d mention it.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer



Meet people who discuss and share your passions. Join them now.

#1761 From: "arvind mishra" <drarvind3@...>
Date:: Sat May 24, 2008 12:12 am
Subject:: Re: It seems to be a golden opportunity.......
drarvind3@...
Send Email Send Email
 
Thanks Gene,
regards,
arvind

2008/5/23 Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>:

My take on this is: enter at your own risk. It's obviously a business. The people running the contest charge you £5 per entry. If they get a few hundred people at a time to enter and pay out only about  £200 per contest, they're pulling in a few hundred (maybe a few thousand) pounds a month.

If you're not familiar with entering contests, I suggest you do a bit of research on the practice to make sure you're entering competitions that actually matter. This one doesn't. It's a business venture run by some outfit called Certys Limited. You, the contest entrant, appear to be the company's prospective cash cow.

Just thought I'd mention it.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer




--
arvind mishra

#1760 From: Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>
Date:: Fri May 23, 2008 4:05 pm
Subject:: Re: It seems to be a golden opportunity.......
gevantry
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
My take on this is: enter at your own risk. It’s obviously a business. The people running the contest charge you £5 per entry. If they get a few hundred people at a time to enter and pay out only about  £200 per contest, they’re pulling in a few hundred (maybe a few thousand) pounds a month.

If you’re not familiar with entering contests, I suggest you do a bit of research on the practice to make sure you’re entering competitions that actually matter. This one doesn’t. It’s a business venture run by some outfit called Certys Limited. You, the contest entrant, appear to be the company’s prospective cash cow.

Just thought I’d mention it.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer

#1759 From: "arvind mishra" <arvind_drmishra@...>
Date:: Fri May 23, 2008 2:25 pm
Subject:: It seems to be a golden opportunity.......
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Friends,
Here is an invitation to those friends on the forum who are inclined to  writing Sf in English.Swapnil as I honestly feel is such an aspiring[and very deserving] guy who could rise to occasion and accept the challenge.
The invitation came through my 'Science Fiction in India'  blog as  a pleasant surprise and it is our moral duty to respond.
I am putting the invitation right here for an easy perusal by you Samaritans and trust this shall not go in vain.
Bimal ji and CMN also have a flair for writing in English and they could also consider the proposal in right earnest.
I wonder if many of other members who are still enjoying a prolonged slumber are awakened to this appeal and respond please !
So here is the appeal from the west -
  

    Dear writer/writing group members-
Well, we are interested in Indian sci-fiction and Indian writing generally. We run a short story competition from the UK and the info below should say it all

    Our latest monthly Global Short Story Competition is open for entries now and we would love you/your members to be involved - and we would love to see some sci-fi entries.

    So if you have not heard about us, what is our background? Well, our previous UK competitions attracted writers from Asia, Europe, Australia and the United States as well as aspiring authors all across the UK and Ireland. So, we got to thinking that the time was ripe a for global short story competition, aimed at showcasing exciting new talent.

    As a published novelist and creative writing tutor, I know there is a lot of talent out there, much of it yet to be discovered. This competition will seek to find, and celebrate, it.

    Already, in our first few competitions, we have had winners from Australia, Canada and the UK.

    We are constantly adding new countries to our competition and entries have come from nations including Italy, France, Romania, Finland, the US, Canada, Israel, Australia, New Zealand, India and South Korea as well as the UK and Ireland.

    The closing day for each competition is the last day of the month. Writers wishing to find out more, or send entries, should visit www.globalshortstories.net The first prize is £100.

    Those who would rather post their entries, instead of going through the website entry system, can send them direct to me at 18 Milbank Court, Darlington, Co Durham DL3 9PF, or to the Certys office at Livingstone House, 29 High Northgate, Darlington, Co Durham, England DL1 1UQ, marked Global Short Story Competition, and containing a £5 entry fee, with the cheque made out to Certys Limited.

    I can be contacted on 01325-463813 or emailed at john.dean@... if you need more information.

    Many thanks for reading this and I do hope you feel you can support this venture. If you re-enter, remember you need to change the registration details - most people tend to use the same details and put a number on the end ie Bill3

    Yours faithfully

    John Dean (Competition administrator)
    May 23, 2008 6:50 AM 

#1758 From: "ML Gupta" <mlguptavns@...>
Date:: Wed May 21, 2008 3:13 pm
Subject:: Re: Re: Re: Science fiction books vis- a'- vis Sci-fi films
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Hi Everybody,
Films are for entertainment and  not  to teach science.More ever films have made a great contribution in popularizing sf however diluted.
ML


On Wed, 21 May 2008 Arvind Mishra wrote :
>Dear CMN
>Thanks for the nice gesture,
>Much has been already deliberated on
>the subject.This form of EYE SCI FI should not be taken
>seriously as their sole aim is to earn money-big money only.They are to
>apply all the formulas to make the films a big box office hit
>masquerading in the name of sci fi since big money is also involved in making of such films. How one can dare,even think of taking any choices !
>Thanks again for keeping me
>awake.
>arvind mishra
>--- On
>Tue, 20/5/08, CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL
><cmnautiyal@yahoo.
>co.uk>
>wrote:
> From: CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@yahoo.
>co.uk>
>Subject: [indianscienceficti
>on] Re: Science fiction books vis-
>  a'- vis  Sci-fi films
>To: indiansciencefictio
>n@yahoogroups.
>co.in
>Date: Tuesday, 20 May, 2008, 3:42 PM
>Dear friends,
>
>Sorry to wake up from the summer siesta.
>
>This has been the longest lull in my memory on this forum.  It's time it rocks again.  Here is an extract from an article of Jim Burge in Interdiscipinary Science reviews, 2002, Vol. 227, p.-165- 168 for your comments:
>
>On page 166, Burge writes:
>
>Science fiction literature, at its best, performs social and philosophical thought experiments, and often involves genuine scientific ideas.  When the genre becomes film, the science seems to get filtered out.  The best that can be hoped for is a single quasi scientific conceit, a what if scenario something like 'suppose someone started making undetectable robots' ('Blade runner'), 'suppose someone used genetic engineering to recreate dinosaurs ('Jurrasic Park'), 'suppose we made contact with a nice extra terrestrial civiisation' ,  or 'suppose we made contact with some nasty extra terrestrial intelligence' ('ET').  Beyond this, the script writer fight shy of followig through the scietific implications of their hypotheses.  The story works itself out well or badly witout any further scientific understanding which might underlie the world in which the characters find themselves.themselv es.
>
>lllustrating with "The Beautiful Mind', Burge adds that 'game theory doesn't constitute a strcutured element of the plot' and that 'films which seem at first to be about science usually turnout on further investigation to be about something else'.
>
>
>On p. 167:
>
>Writer believes that Crichton's book was much better than the Jurrasic Pak film.  It happened 'despite the fact that he himself was the scriptwriter and he is no mean director himself'!'
>
>He says, 'scratch a film which seems to have a scientific content and you will find nothing but a different genre in disguise'. It is as if laws of nature come in the way of good story telling.'
>
>He further writes, 'The failure to respond to science does seem to be specific to film: books (and indeed theatre) have a more creditable record.'
>
>These should provide enough food forthought and comments.
>
>Wake up please.
>
>CMN
>
>
>Dr. Chandra Mohan Nautiyal
>MSc (UOR/IIT-R); PhD (PRL/ GU); FGS (I); F-NCSTC-NW; Member Executive, Vigyan Parishad
>
>Scientist-in- Charge, Radiocarbon Lab.
>Geophysical and Geochemical Investigations in Relation to Quaternary Palaeoclimate Reconstruction
>BSIP, 53, University Road, Lucknow- 226007.  INDIA
>Phone :
>0522-2712218 (Res), 2740008, 2740011 (Off),      Mob : 091-09415107078
>
>http://www.geocitie s.com/cmnautiyal /cmnautiyal. html
>
>--- On
>Mon, 12/5/08, arvind mishra
><drarvind3@gmail. com>
>wrote:
> From: arvind mishra <drarvind3@gmail. com>
>Subject: Re: [indianscienceficti on] Science Communication Journal
>To: indiansciencefictio n@yahoogroups. co.in
>Date: Monday, 12 May, 2008, 5:52 PM
>A great site indeed.Congrats for your coming article ...
>And thanks for forum's mention...
>regards,
>arvind
>2008/5/12 CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <
>cmnautiyal@yahoo. co.uk
>>:
>Dear Friends,
>
>Recently I came across a journal of science communication 'JCOM' which is published (online) from Italy quarterly with editors from several countries (Italy, Brazil, Argentina and France).
>
>The journal is free to access and is indexed in several reference works.
>
>The links are
>
>JCOM
>Journal of Science Communication
>http://jcom. sissa.it
>SISSA
>e-mail:
>jcom-eo@jcom. sissa.it
>
>All its previous issues are avialable online.
>
>Similarly Indian Journal of Science Communication is also free to access online and old issues are also available.
>
>Those interested may consult these.  A paper of mine is due to appear in the former inissue to be published on 21st of June. Therein our forum and our effort of writing a joint science ficion is mentioned too.
>
>CMN
>Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage.
>Get it now
>--
>arvind mishra
>Bring your gang together. Do your thing.
>Find your favourite Yahoo! Group.
> From Chandigarh to Chennai - find friends all over India.
>Click here.
>



Shaadi

#1757 From: Arvind Mishra <arvind_drmishra@...>
Date:: Wed May 21, 2008 11:45 am
Subject:: Re: Re: Science fiction books vis- a'- vis Sci-fi films
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Dear CMN
Thanks for the nice gesture,
Much has been already deliberated on
the subject.This form of EYE SCI FI should not be taken
seriously as their sole aim is to earn money-big money only.They are to
apply all the formulas to make the films a big box office hit
masquerading in the name of sci fi since big money is also involved in making of such films. How one can dare,even think of taking any choices !
Thanks again for keeping me
awake.
arvind mishra

--- On Tue, 20/5/08, CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...> wrote:
From: CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...>
Subject: [indiansciencefiction] Re: Science fiction books vis- a'- vis Sci-fi films
To: indiansciencefiction@...
Date: Tuesday, 20 May, 2008, 3:42 PM

Dear friends,

 

Sorry to wake up from the summer siesta.

 

This has been the longest lull in my memory on this forum.  It's time it rocks again.  Here is an extract from an article of Jim Burge in Interdiscipinary Science reviews, 2002, Vol. 227, p.-165- 168 for your comments:

 

On page 166, Burge writes:

 

Science fiction literature, at its best, performs social and philosophical thought experiments, and often involves genuine scientific ideas.  When the genre becomes film, the science seems to get filtered out.  The best that can be hoped for is a single quasi scientific conceit, a what if scenario something like 'suppose someone started making undetectable robots' ('Blade runner'), 'suppose someone used genetic engineering to recreate dinosaurs ('Jurrasic Park'), 'suppose we made contact with a nice extra terrestrial civiisation' ,  or 'suppose we made contact with some nasty extra terrestrial intelligence' ('ET').  Beyond this, the script writer fight shy of followig through the scietific implications of their hypotheses.  The story works itself out well or badly witout any further scientific understanding which might underlie the world in which the characters find themselves.themselv es.

 

lllustrating with "The Beautiful Mind', Burge adds that 'game theory doesn't constitute a strcutured element of the plot' and that 'films which seem at first to be about science usually turnout on further investigation to be about something else'.

 

 

On p. 167:

 

Writer believes that Crichton's book was much better than the Jurrasic Pak film.  It happened 'despite the fact that he himself was the scriptwriter and he is no mean director himself'!'

 

He says, 'scratch a film which seems to have a scientific content and you will find nothing but a different genre in disguise'. It is as if laws of nature come in the way of good story telling.'

 

He further writes, 'The failure to respond to science does seem to be specific to film: books (and indeed theatre) have a more creditable record.'

 

These should provide enough food forthought and comments.

 

Wake up please.

 

CMN

 

 

Dr. Chandra Mohan Nautiyal
MSc (UOR/IIT-R); PhD (PRL/ GU); FGS (I); F-NCSTC-NW; Member Executive, Vigyan Parishad
 
Scientist-in- Charge, Radiocarbon Lab.
Geophysical and Geochemical Investigations in Relation to Quaternary Palaeoclimate Reconstruction
BSIP, 53, University Road, Lucknow- 226007.  INDIA
Phone : 0522-2712218 (Res), 2740008, 2740011 (Off),      Mob : 091-09415107078
 

 


--- On Mon, 12/5/08, arvind mishra <drarvind3@gmail. com> wrote:
From: arvind mishra <drarvind3@gmail. com>
Subject: Re: [indianscienceficti on] Science Communication Journal
To: indiansciencefictio n@yahoogroups. co.in
Date: Monday, 12 May, 2008, 5:52 PM

A great site indeed.Congrats for your coming article ...
And thanks for forum's mention...
regards,
arvind

2008/5/12 CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@yahoo. co.uk>:


Dear Friends,
 
Recently I came across a journal of science communication 'JCOM' which is published (online) from Italy quarterly with editors from several countries (Italy, Brazil, Argentina and France).
 
The journal is free to access and is indexed in several reference works.
 
The links are
 
JCOM
Journal of Science Communication
http://jcom. sissa.it
SISSA
e-mail: jcom-eo@jcom. sissa.it
 
All its previous issues are avialable online.
 
Similarly Indian Journal of Science Communication is also free to access online and old issues are also available.
 
Those interested may consult these.  A paper of mine is due to appear in the former inissue to be published on 21st of June. Therein our forum and our effort of writing a joint science ficion is mentioned too.
 
CMN


Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage. Get it now



--
arvind mishra


Bring your gang together. Do your thing. Find your favourite Yahoo! Group.



From Chandigarh to Chennai - find friends all over India. Click here.

#1756 From: CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...>
Date:: Tue May 20, 2008 10:12 am
Subject:: Re: Science fiction books vis- a'- vis Sci-fi films
cmnautiyal
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Dear friends,

 

Sorry to wake up from the summer siesta.

 

This has been the longest lull in my memory on this forum.  It's time it rocks again.  Here is an extract from an article of Jim Burge in Interdiscipinary Science reviews, 2002, Vol. 227, p.-165- 168 for your comments:

 

On page 166, Burge writes:

 

Science fiction literature, at its best, performs social and philosophical thought experiments, and often involves genuine scientific ideas.  When the genre becomes film, the science seems to get filtered out.  The best that can be hoped for is a single quasi scientific conceit, a what if scenario something like 'suppose someone started making undetectable robots' ('Blade runner'), 'suppose someone used genetic engineering to recreate dinosaurs ('Jurrasic Park'), 'suppose we made contact with a nice extra terrestrial civiisation',  or 'suppose we made contact with some nasty extra terrestrial intelligence' ('ET').  Beyond this, the script writer fight shy of followig through the scietific implications of their hypotheses.  The story works itself out well or badly witout any further scientific understanding which might underlie the world in which the characters find themselves.themselves.

 

lllustrating with "The Beautiful Mind', Burge adds that 'game theory doesn't constitute a strcutured element of the plot' and that 'films which seem at first to be about science usually turnout on further investigation to be about something else'.

 

 

On p. 167:

 

Writer believes that Crichton's book was much better than the Jurrasic Pak film.  It happened 'despite the fact that he himself was the scriptwriter and he is no mean director himself'!'

 

He says, 'scratch a film which seems to have a scientific content and you will find nothing but a different genre in disguise'. It is as if laws of nature come in the way of good story telling.'

 

He further writes, 'The failure to respond to science does seem to be specific to film: books (and indeed theatre) have a more creditable record.'

 

These should provide enough food forthought and comments.

 

Wake up please.

 

CMN

 

 

Dr. Chandra Mohan Nautiyal
MSc (UOR/IIT-R); PhD (PRL/ GU); FGS (I); F-NCSTC-NW; Member Executive, Vigyan Parishad
 
Scientist-in-Charge, Radiocarbon Lab.
Geophysical and Geochemical Investigations in Relation to Quaternary Palaeoclimate Reconstruction
BSIP, 53, University Road, Lucknow- 226007.  INDIA
Phone : 0522-2712218 (Res), 2740008, 2740011 (Off),      Mob : 091-09415107078
 

 


--- On Mon, 12/5/08, arvind mishra <drarvind3@...> wrote:
From: arvind mishra <drarvind3@...>
Subject: Re: [indiansciencefiction] Science Communication Journal
To: indiansciencefiction@...
Date: Monday, 12 May, 2008, 5:52 PM

A great site indeed.Congrats for your coming article ...
And thanks for forum's mention...
regards,
arvind

2008/5/12 CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@yahoo. co.uk>:


Dear Friends,
 
Recently I came across a journal of science communication 'JCOM' which is published (online) from Italy quarterly with editors from several countries (Italy, Brazil, Argentina and France).
 
The journal is free to access and is indexed in several reference works.
 
The links are
 
JCOM
Journal of Science Communication
http://jcom. sissa.it
SISSA
e-mail: jcom-eo@jcom. sissa.it
 
All its previous issues are avialable online.
 
Similarly Indian Journal of Science Communication is also free to access online and old issues are also available.
 
Those interested may consult these.  A paper of mine is due to appear in the former inissue to be published on 21st of June. Therein our forum and our effort of writing a joint science ficion is mentioned too.
 
CMN


Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage. Get it now



--
arvind mishra


Bring your gang together. Do your thing. Find your favourite Yahoo! Group.

#1755 From: Vishwa Mohan Tiwari <onevishwa@...>
Date:: Mon May 12, 2008 3:49 pm
Subject:: RE: Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train
onevishwa
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Arvind Jee Dhanyawaad
vmt


 
Vishwa Mohan Tiwari



To: indiansciencefiction@...
From: arvind_drmishra@...
Date: Sat, 10 May 2008 20:01:29 +0530
Subject: RE: [indiansciencefiction] Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train

Not Again,
Wish you a very comfortable summer  touring and fruitful lecturing.
regards,
arvind

arvind mishra

--- On Sat, 10/5/08, Vishwa Mohan Tiwari <onevishwa@hotmail.com> wrote:
From: Vishwa Mohan Tiwari <onevishwa@hotmail.com>
Subject: RE: [indiansciencefiction] Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train
To: indiansciencefiction@yahoogroups.co.in
Date: Saturday, 10 May, 2008, 12:33 PM

Friends,
I had been extremely busy with my lecture tour to Aligarh, Bhopak and jabalpur. Regretfully I could not participate in the intelletual discusions on the forum. I am leaving tomorrow and would return on 29th May.
Till then all the best to you all.
VMT



 
Vishwa Mohan Tiwari



To: indiansciencefictio n@yahoogroups. co.in
From: zeashanzaidi@ yahoo.com
Date: Fri, 9 May 2008 22:17:06 -0700
Subject: [indianscienceficti on] Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train



Stay in touch when you're away with Windows Live Messenger. IM anytime you're online.



Get Free (PRODUCT) RED™ Emoticons, Winks and Display Pics. Check it out!

#1754 From: "arvind mishra" <drarvind3@...>
Date:: Mon May 12, 2008 12:22 pm
Subject:: Re: Science Communication Journal
drarvind3@...
Send Email Send Email
 
A great site indeed.Congrats for your coming article ...
And thanks for forum's mention...
regards,
arvind

2008/5/12 CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...>:


Dear Friends,
 
Recently I came across a journal of science communication 'JCOM' which is published (online) from Italy quarterly with editors from several countries (Italy, Brazil, Argentina and France).
 
The journal is free to access and is indexed in several reference works.
 
The links are
 
JCOM
Journal of Science Communication
http://jcom.sissa.it
SISSA
e-mail: jcom-eo@...
 
All its previous issues are avialable online.
 
Similarly Indian Journal of Science Communication is also free to access online and old issues are also available.
 
Those interested may consult these.  A paper of mine is due to appear in the former inissue to be published on 21st of June. Therein our forum and our effort of writing a joint science ficion is mentioned too.
 
CMN


Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage. Get it now



--
arvind mishra

#1753 From: CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...>
Date:: Mon May 12, 2008 10:44 am
Subject:: Science Communication Journal
cmnautiyal
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Dear Friends,
 
Recently I came across a journal of science communication 'JCOM' which is published (online) from Italy quarterly with editors from several countries (Italy, Brazil, Argentina and France).
 
The journal is free to access and is indexed in several reference works.
 
The links are
 
JCOM
Journal of Science Communication
http://jcom.sissa.it
SISSA
e-mail: jcom-eo@...
 
All its previous issues are avialable online.
 
Similarly Indian Journal of Science Communication is also free to access online and old issues are also available.
 
Those interested may consult these.  A paper of mine is due to appear in the former inissue to be published on 21st of June. Therein our forum and our effort of writing a joint science ficion is mentioned too.
 
CMN


Unlimited freedom, unlimited storage. Get it now

#1752 From: "arvind mishra" <arvind_drmishra@...>
Date:: Mon May 12, 2008 1:51 am
Subject:: Re: Proceedings of 8th IASFSN National SF Conferene :A Review-1
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 

Friends,
I have often wondered if sf has some sort of  regionalism/cultural factions  incorporated in its  nature  in addition to its universal common elements familiar to most  of us.
And I was impressed by the discussion on the topic in between Prof. James Gunn,USA and Dr.Bal Phondke,Prof.Yashvant Deshpande and Shri A.P.Deshpande all Indian  sf  luminaries, published in the said  proceedings.
When asked whether sf writers could be classified as Indian sf writers,American sf writers ,European sf writers,James Gunn replied that categorizations like these seemed justifiable as  culture also plays an important role  in  shaping  the ideas  of  sf writers.He said ,"...every writer is a composite of kind of genetic inheritance  that he/she gets from the parents and grand parents modified by the kind of  culture that teaches him what is  important in life....... I certainly noticed cultural differences in the stories of the authors while selecting the stories from 15 countries for 6th volume of 'the road to sf' ..there were commonality but in certain countries authors were far more influenced by fantasy elements....".I quite agree to Prof.Gunn and often notice that Indian sf too incorporates relatively more fantasy elements  and  comparatively  large number of sf writers are tempted to include fantasy in their works.
But the point which worries me is the tendency of relegation of sf literature  further down to even the levels of small geographical and cultural  entities  like states  and  vernaculars.
If this goes unbated I am afraid sf may loose its universal identity and may plunge into the state of an 'identity crisis '  as a genre.
Cant it  be recommended that authors of sf worldwide must adhere to certain features of sf  by which it is easily recognizable internationally.
And what are these features ?....any true sf buff is already familiar with  but in case there remains some doubts the same  could be addressed in  meetings ,gatherings on sf and even on forums like this one from time to time.This is in fact a continuing process and not like something akin to any dogmas and fatwas of religious  world-once established never changed.
Your opinion on this issue is very much solicited ......
--- In indiansciencefiction@..., anant deshpande <apd1942@...> wrote:
>
>
> Dear All,
>
> Inspite of it Mr.Laxman Londhe,an SF writer in Marathi got an opportunity to get his SF,`Einstien the Second`in ,`The Road to Science Fiction Around The World`published by Prof.James Gunn,a Professor of the university of Kansas,USA,Head of SF dept.
>
> A.P.Deshpande
>
>
> To: indiansciencefiction@...: onevishwa@...: Sun, 20 Apr 2008 09:55:31 -0700Subject: RE: [indiansciencefiction] Proceedings of 8th IASFSN National SF Conferene :A Review-1
>
>
>
>
> Shri Arvind Mishra wrote :Being a multilingual country with almost 2 dozen languages India stands divided in its contributions towards enrichment of sf at the global level.Our whole energy seems to be exhausted in promoting and boasting our own regional achievements all the time -scattered and sporadic efforts like that may be a cause why Indian sf is not coming up to terms with contemporary world sf .Even though we have two dozen languages, our languages are spoken by really large numbers. Hindi is the second, Telugu is the seventh(if I remeber reight), and Bengali is tenth or so. Our top 4 languages are in the top ten or so languages of the world. ( I may be wrong in my numbers, but the concept remains valid) Most of us spend an important part of our learning time in learning a foriegn language for the specific purpose of building our carriers. We live in a different language and work in a different language. There are two different compartments in our psyche for the two languages. We are a divided personality.Most of us neither know English well not our own language, having lost the love for it.If we live and work in our languages, we can produce great literature, including SF in all of them. After all other nations with smaller populations are producing great authors and sientists. Israel, Japan and Korea are some examples that we can learn fromvmt
>
> Vishwa Mohan Tiwari
>
>
> To: indiansciencefiction@...: arvind_drmishra@...: Fri, 18 Apr 2008 11:03:05 +0000Subject: [indiansciencefiction] Proceedings of 8th IASFSN National SF Conferene :A Review-1
>
>
> Indian Sf :Conflicts and contradictions !Just finished reading of the above mentioned proceedings sent to me by Marathi Vidhyan Parishad-[courtesy:Shri Anant Deshpande].The way I feel about the literary compilation is expressed in the following lines.You may call it a review if you so wish[for all practical purposes].Shri Devendra Mewari , a noted Hindi sf writer observes that the present scenario of Hindi sf writing can not be stated to be an exiting and productive activity.One is tempted to ponder over the reasons if the scenario as projected by Mr. Mewari is at all correct.Although I do not fully agree to the statement I wish to submit that there are really certain conflicts and constraints which are of course hampering the natural development of the genre in India.Being a multilingual country with almost 2 dozen languages India stands divided in its contributions towards enrichment of sf at the global level.Our whole energy seems to be exhausted in promoting and boasting our own regional achievements all the time -scattered and sporadic efforts like that may be a cause why Indian sf is not coming up to terms with contemporary world sf .We have perhaps not identified ourselves so far as one and unified entity / force in focusing our attention to promote the Indian sf brand at global levels.Still divided in factions our contributions do not seem to be perceptible .In an another scholarly write-up entitled , 'sf in Kannad '[the state language of KARNATAKA state] Mr.Rajshekhar Bhoosnurmath has rightly stated that he does not like the idea of branding and highlighting Indian sf in many languages with some pride usually associated with them.He clarifies that he has never isolated /identified himself as a Kannad writer only.The central thought behind this blog also echoes the stand of Mr.Bhooshnurmath that we are Indian sf writer first and then whatever else .There must be an unified approach to promote Indian sf and the beginning has already been made ......[more next..but comments are welcome for fueling the thoughts for next part....]
>
> Get in touch in an instant. Get Windows Live Messenger now.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> _________________________________________________________________
> Technology : Catch up on updates on the latest Gadgets, Reviews, Gaming and Tips to use technology etc.
> http://computing.in.msn.com/
>

#1751 From: Arvind Mishra <arvind_drmishra@...>
Date:: Sat May 10, 2008 2:31 pm
Subject:: RE: Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train
arvind_drmishra
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Not Again,
Wish you a very comfortable summer  touring and fruitful lecturing.
regards,
arvind

arvind mishra

--- On Sat, 10/5/08, Vishwa Mohan Tiwari <onevishwa@...> wrote:
From: Vishwa Mohan Tiwari <onevishwa@...>
Subject: RE: [indiansciencefiction] Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train
To: indiansciencefiction@...
Date: Saturday, 10 May, 2008, 12:33 PM

Friends,
I had been extremely busy with my lecture tour to Aligarh, Bhopak and jabalpur. Regretfully I could not participate in the intelletual discusions on the forum. I am leaving tomorrow and would return on 29th May.
Till then all the best to you all.
VMT


 
Vishwa Mohan Tiwari



To: indiansciencefictio n@yahoogroups. co.in
From: zeashanzaidi@ yahoo.com
Date: Fri, 9 May 2008 22:17:06 -0700
Subject: [indianscienceficti on] Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train



Stay in touch when you're away with Windows Live Messenger. IM anytime you're online.

#1750 From: Vishwa Mohan Tiwari <onevishwa@...>
Date:: Sat May 10, 2008 7:03 am
Subject:: RE: Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train
onevishwa
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
Friends,
I had been extremely busy with my lecture tour to Aligarh, Bhopak and jabalpur. Regretfully I could not participate in the intelletual discusions on the forum. I am leaving tomorrow and would return on 29th May.
Till then all the best to you all.
VMT


 
Vishwa Mohan Tiwari



To: indiansciencefiction@...
From: zeashanzaidi@...
Date: Fri, 9 May 2008 22:17:06 -0700
Subject: [indiansciencefiction] Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train



Stay in touch when you're away with Windows Live Messenger. IM anytime you're online.

#1749 From: zeashan zaidi <zeashanzaidi@...>
Date:: Sat May 10, 2008 5:17 am
Subject:: Fwd:Latest Model of Bullet Train
zeashanzaidi
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
#1748 From: "arvind mishra" <drarvind3@...>
Date:: Fri May 9, 2008 3:58 pm
Subject:: Re: Re: How the word 'Clarke 'is pronounced ?
drarvind3@...
Send Email Send Email
 
"Boy, did we grind him into little pieces on that one, heh-heh."
-Gene
No Gene ,How could we do that ?  The FORUM is characteristically an extra polite entity and  you know it already .
We cant offend any body's feelings and outrage the modesty  ....thanks  for  comments  .
arvind
2008/5/9 Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>:

On 5/9/08 9:28 PM, "CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL" <cmnautiyal@...> wrote:


Friends,  There is a word popular in Mumbai- kachumar, it's for a mesh of khira/cucumber, tomato etc.

Sounds like some kind of coleslaw. "Yeah, the old guy got 2,999 words right in that translation, just spot on superlative work, but he really blew it on 'quantum scrim.' Boy, did we grind him into little pieces on that one, heh-heh. And it turns out quantum scrim is a neologism any way, so who's to know? His guess was as good as Schrödinger's Cat's!"

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer
----
"(You Are Here) Topquark" in Strange Horizons:
http://www.strangehorizons.com/2008/20080421/topquark-p.shtml




--
arvind mishra

#1747 From: "arvind mishra" <drarvind3@...>
Date:: Fri May 9, 2008 3:49 pm
Subject:: Re: Re: How the word 'Clarke 'is pronounced ?
drarvind3@...
Send Email Send Email
 
Did  we really made the guy the Kachumar salad ? I do not think it beause,1-His identity was not disclosed.
 2-It was an open mind discussion  with  malice towards none.Academic discussions are like that and every one should take them with that spirit only.
I offer the toast to the anonymous translator on the behalf of the  Forum  but  wonder  if   the  fellow is listening to us.
arvind

2008/5/9 CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL <cmnautiyal@...>:

Friends,

 

There is a word popular in Mumbai- kachumar, it's for a mesh of khira/cucumber, tomato tec.   Do I see the poor translater in that situation?  Some bright and talented guy beautifully translated a, say, 3000 word article and we didn't have a word of appreciation for the 2999 words but made a kachumar of him over one word, which, as many of us expressed, is not the crux!

 

Shall we raise a toast to the translater (I don't know who he is) and say we always do it to each other but never mean malice but take it as academic excercise to benefit from each other's wisdom/ knowledge, whatever is that worth? 

 

Will someone please add something appropriate for the occasion?

 

CMN

 



--- On Tue, 6/5/08, Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...> wrote:

From: Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>
Subject: Re: [indiansciencefiction] Re: How the word 'Clarke 'is pronounced ?
To: "indiansciencefiction" <indiansciencefiction@...>
Date: Tuesday, 6 May, 2008, 2:41 PM


On 5/6/08 4:34 PM, "swapnil.bhartiya" <arnieswap@gmail. com> wrote:


Its is pronounced as "klahrk". If you check any Clarke interviews available on YouTube you will know this IS the correct pronunciation.

In most varieties of North American English, there would be a "hard" /r/ pronounced as in klARk. (Some varieties of American English would drop the hard /r/.) British RP would make the /r/ into an /ah/ as is KlAHk. If your confusion arises from how that "R" is pronounced, it doesn't really matter. It's going to change slightly from dialect to dialect of English. Of course, there are some who will make it an issue if only because there are always some who firmly believe the is a set proper way that English is supposed to be pronounced that is superior to all other ways. Some British people insist it is the Received Pronunciation of the Queen's English. Many American say nonsense to that, the purest form of English pronunciation is to be found in Nebraska.

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer



From Chandigarh to Chennai - find friends all over India. Click here.



--
arvind mishra

#1746 From: Gene van Troyer <gevantry@...>
Date:: Fri May 9, 2008 1:37 pm
Subject:: Re: Re: How the word 'Clarke 'is pronounced ?
gevantry
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 
On 5/9/08 9:28 PM, "CHANDRA MOHAN NAUTIYAL" <cmnautiyal@...> wrote:

Friends,  There is a word popular in Mumbai- kachumar, it's for a mesh of khira/cucumber, tomato etc.

Sounds like some kind of coleslaw. “Yeah, the old guy got 2,999 words right in that translation, just spot on superlative work, but he really blew it on ‘quantum scrim.’ Boy, did we grind him into little pieces on that one, heh-heh. And it turns out quantum scrim is a neologism any way, so who’s to know? His guess was as good as Schrödinger’s Cat’s!”

Cheers,

Gene van Troyer
----
"(You Are Here) Topquark" in Strange Horizons:
http://www.strangehorizons.com/2008/20080421/topquark-p.shtml


Messages 1746 - 1775 of 3488   Newest  |  < Newer  |  Older >  |  Oldest
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help