Sign In
New User? Register
jatropha · Say No To Jatropha
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can set the sort order of messages? Just click on the link in the date column. Your preferences will be remembered, so you don't have to do it again when you return.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
India's Big Plans for Biodiesel   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #569 of 892 |
Here is a comment from Pankaj Ballabh working in Vidhya Bhawan Insitute Udaipur.
 
Viren
 
 

I really do not understand what TERI has achieved and proved- of course Jathropa grows on wastelands! TERI could have driven around in Jhadol, Kotra indeed any part of Rural Udaipur and seen it for themselves and avoided research. There are several problems with the “bio-diesel” hype. The standard (in sense of that most practitioners are aware of it) problem of course is that most bio-diesel (including Jathropha) is net negative on energy. Also the recent articles on net would indicate that the productivity numbers being talked about are for irrigated and fertile soils, and yields in “wastelands’ (is there any wastelands in India in any case) are less than half (it will of course be nice if the TERI shares data on soil fertility, irrigation  and corresponding yield).

 

I also saw the bio-diesel plant at Indian Institute of Petroleum at Dehradun- unfortunately it did not look as simple as heat and add one ingredient. It seemed a complex process and is indeed akin to a formal refinery. This is of course if you intend to produce something that is Euro IV compatible and fit for modern diesels- anything would go in a village pump-set.

 

I personally also find the idea of genetic modification on a plant that propagates by seed and by vegetative means, scattered all over rural areas, fairly scary. Are there any details of the safeguards that TERI is adopting and their audit and oversight processes?

 

Best Regards

 

Pankaj

 


From: Viren Lobo [mailto:vlobo62@...]
Sent: Saturday, March 01, 2008 1:31 AM
To: Juned Khan; Dr Jagdish K Purohit; jagdeesh menon; Seva Mandir; SevaMandir-NRD; fes BHL; FES UDR; Fes Pratapgarh; Anand; Prayas; Jawahar Singh; ramesh nandwana; Prayatna Samiti; JJVS; hvvs@...; samarthak Samiti; Astha; Astha Bhanwar Singh; Mangi Lal Gujjar; Shalini Bhutani; kanchikohli@...; Dr Leena Gupta; Giriraj Kishore Kumawat; Pankaj Oudhia; Pankaj Ballabh GM; msr@...; knd51@...; K N Joshi; purnendu kavoori
Subject: India's Big Plans for Biodiesel

 

Sent by Dr Jagdishk Kumar Purohit , FYI and comments

 

 

Viren

 

 

Technology Review - Published by MIT

 

India's Big Plans for Biodiesel

Researchers are developing new methods for cultivating a plant called jatropha.

By Michael Fitzgerald
December 27, 2006


Biodiesel could be an important renewable substitute for fossil fuels. And, in certain parts of the world, governments and some corporations consider the jatropha plant, common in hot climates, one of the most promising sources of biodiesel. The plant can grow in wastelands, and it yields more than four times as much fuel per hectare as soybean, and more than ten times that of corn. But the commercial-scale cultivation of jatropha, which has not previously been grown as a crop, raises several significant challenges.

This year, the Energy and Resources Institute (TERI), an Indian research group, launched a 10-year, $9.4 million project to research issues involved in taking jatropha from seed to filling station. One challenge is growing the plant in poor soil.

The first crops of jatropha, planted in what was wasteland, have now flowered, says Alok Adholeya, director of TERI's Biotechnology and Management of Bioresources division. "It proves that we can do this," he says. He and other researchers at TERI spent five years testing different mycorrhiza microorganisms, symbiotic fungi that improve the ability of many plants to grow in poor soil. Adholeya's team found that the most effective was a fungus in the glomus species (he is not currently disclosing the exact fungus), which improves jatropha yields by 15 percent.

The TERI project is working in rural Andra Pradesh, a state in southeast India, collaborating with local financial institutions to develop loan guarantees to fund seed purchases; it's also collaborating with insurers to back the farmers against potential losses. In addition, it had to educate the farmers on how to cultivate the plant.

So far, the project has signed up 5,000 farmers representing 1,000 hectares of land. The goal is to have 8,000 hectares under cultivation by March 2008, and Adholeya says that the success of the first crops has drawn interest from many more farmers. By the end of 2008, TERI plans to have a production facility producing biodiesel from jatropha. Eventually, it aims to produce 90 million liters of biodiesel annually.

Adholeya is also working on genetically modifying jatropha to improve its yields. He leads a team of 20 microbiologists, molecular biologists, and field breeders who are looking for the genes in jatropha that cause it to fruit so that they can enhance the percentage of oil in the seed. He expects that it will take 18 months to isolate the genes and begin working to enhance them. The researchers plan to use a technique called molecular-assisted breeding, in which they identify a gene of interest, select particular genotypes, and breed them. Adholeya expects that by 2012, modified jatropha plants will be in cultivation.

He says that the Indian government, taking note of a report by TERI, is considering a national initiative around developing jatropha crops as a major source of fuel. That report calls for India to plant 400,000 hectares of jatropha in 22 of India's 28 states.

India is not alone in its interest in jatropha. Indonesia's government is promoting jatropha cultivation, as are several governments in Africa. Jatropha is attractive because of several desirable properties: it can grow in poor soil and survive drought; it's a perennial with an economic life of about 35 to 40 years; and it only needs two to three years to develop into a cash crop.

Jatropha seeds, when crushed, produce large quantities of an oil that can easily be converted to biodiesel that performs at levels close to that of conventional diesel oil. In fact, a hectare of jatropha produces 1,892 liters of fuel, which is better than rapeseed and far better than soybean or corn, according to data gathered by the Global Petroleum Club, an energy networking organization funded by the private-equity firm Forrest Equity Management.

"Jatropha is a one-stage conversion [to biodiesel]," says Adholeya, explaining that converting the plant oil to an oil that can be burned as fuel requires only one stage of heating and mixing with methanol. The resulting fuel, he says, "is a very good quality diesel that can be used in any transport vehicle."

 



Tue Mar 4, 2008 10:15 am

vitits
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #569 of 892 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Here is a comment from Pankaj Ballabh working in Vidhya Bhawan Insitute Udaipur. Viren I really do not understand what TERI has achieved and proved- of course...
Viren Lobo
vitits
Offline Send Email
Mar 4, 2008
10:33 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help