From: KutchScience@hotmail
To: sng.curator@... ; ron.koczor@... ;
phillips@... ; comments@...
Sent: Monday, May 16, 2005 3:12 PM
Subject: Confusions in Contradicting Diagrams. diagrammatic presentation of an
Asteroid MN2004 contradicting one to another. so confusing for their conclusion
too


Dear Friends of Science and Astronomy,

It looks that diagramatic presentation is contradictory to the wording. needs
more detailed presentation. so we can discuss the detail in further details.

1) if the asteroid MN2004 is changing its path by Earth gravitation - what
degree of daviation is expected and at what unit speed of asteroid.

2) Or the daviation by Earth gravitation is driving the asteroid to the MOON or
SUn to its impact distruction on either MOON's dark side of the DAY or on the
SUN itself?

3) Diagramatic presentation is like the asteroid is passing near Earth and so
gravitation bend its path so as that passes between the earth and the Moon and
so as to pass towards the Sun. SUN is also in the same angular direction as the
MOON on the that time.So does THE MOON will change the course of asteroid again
towrds opposite direction than the EARTH did. like a zig zag direction - it
looks that is not possible.


Both Earth and Asteroid MN2004 orbits are about approximately at similarly
distant from Sun. so coming close to each other every year too. AND also both
are unidirectional. (seen by appellate). so they approach each other at the
speed of difference of the speed of those two. eg (Speed Earth -speed of
Asteroid MN2004) which is just 1to - few km /sec only. and this makes sense to
avoid collision, if they had contra directional orbit - there was no collision
course. and only difference is angular orbital crossing at certain distance as
in 3D both orbits has a certain distance at near the crossing points in 2D.





This appellate of the day before - 12 Apr 2029 - just a day before.







13 Apr 2029 Sun and Moon in same direction -(AMAVASYA) just few angles.



A) B)

A) & B) These both diagrams show real situation and sun and Moon @ nearly at
90 degree from Asteroid orbit and earths position at that time



C ) D )



C ) & D) These both diagrams show Unreal situation and sun and Moon can not
be @ this position to the Asteroid orbit position at that time SIMILARLY same
apply for diagram Below E (These situation creates wrong interpretations
-Asteroid MN2004 may go to Moon's Dark unseen surface or to the SUN. or may go
to a LONG tour orbit like a comet )



E)





This may be a real situation seen by the appellate of the day before - 13 Apr
2029 - just a day before.



This diagrammatic situation more likely and so No collision is possible.
Situation may be different if Asteroid MN2004 was in the same position after a
fortnight. means if it was late by 14 days when Moon is in opposite position
than that of @ this situation.



With Compliments from: Dr. BHUDIA : Science Group Of INDIA.
http://uk.groups.yahoo.com/group/venustransit_2004/
President:"Kutch Science Foundation".
Founder :"Kutch Amateurs Astronomers Club - Bhuj - Kutch".
Life Member:"kutch Itihaas Parishad".
kutchscience@..., kutchscience@...,
http://uk.geocities.com/wildlifeofkutch/
http://www.geocities.com/kutchscience
http://profiles.yahoo.com/kutchscience2000
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/scienceclubofindia
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/kutchscience
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/kachchh
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/bhuj

Do visit our ABOVE Clubs/Groups of Science club of India & Science






[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]